The Business of Comics for August 14th, 2026
AI Detection Tools Are Coming: The AI apocalypse recently took a new turn in a way that might help creators. Anthropic announced that it is adding a function that will watermark all AI-generated text and images, beginning in August. This move was forced on Anthropic by new regulations from countries like the United Kingdom and US states like California. Other AI platforms are also planning to add watermarks to comply with these new laws.
This move could reduce the uncertainty surrounding comic book scripts and artwork generated by AI, but this may not be the Infinity Gauntlet that will erase AI from comics completely. It can be a powerful tool for creators and publishers trying to prevent AI from tainting their comics. However, those who want to publish AI work won’t bother using this system. Also, it will probably still be possible for someone to retype or trace AI-generated content to avoid the watermark. Finally, it is unclear how easy it will be for retailers and readers to see this watermark in comics, especially if they buy the print version. But given the lack of copyright protection granted to AI comics, the risk of losing publishing and movie deals when AI usage is alleged, and the general negative image surrounding AI comics, the addition of the watermark is another setback for the use of this technology in the industry.
Dangers of Distribution: There have been several developments in comic book distribution since San Diego Comic Con ended. Diamond finally settled their lawsuit against the publishers trying to recover their consignment inventory. Small press initiatives attempting to replace Diamond are gaining traction. Digital comic publishers are rolling out print-on-demand options for direct-to-consumer sales, and some smaller publishers are signing deals to become imprints of larger players.
One concerning trend that I’ve seen over the past few months is the rise of the comic book aggregators, or sub-distributors. Basically, major distributors like Lunar or Simon & Schuster aren’t willing to take on new independent publishers in the same way Diamond did in the past. So, some small publishers who already have an account with a distributor are offering to act as a sub-distributor, inserting themselves into the distribution channel in exchange for a percentage of the sale, and in some cases, an additional fee. This creates a situation where an indie publisher has to share the cover price of the comic with the retailer, the distributor, and the sub-distributor before they can attempt to cover their own production, printing, and shipping costs.
Considering how tight profit margins are for independent comics, and considering that most sub-distribution contracts that I’ve seen don’t guarantee distribution, independent publishers need to be very clear about what they are getting and what they are giving up, before signing a deal with a sub-distributor. In fact, given the current convoluted state of direct market distribution, this is a good time to take a step back, to determine if your book even needs to be in a comic book shop in the first place.
A New Tax on Adult Comics: Adult or not-safe-for-work comics have always faced challenges in the American market. In the late 1900s, criminal cases against underground comix led to the creation of the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund. Before and after COVID, right-wing fanatics launched persistent attacks on inclusionary comics in schools and libraries. Earlier this year, Stripe and Kickstarter tried and failed to institute economic censorship of adult crowdfunded comics. Now, Mixam, an online print-on-demand service popular with independent comic creators, has added what amounts to a new tax on adult comics. According to the site, their new self-reporting content ratings are gathered to ensure your product takes the smoothest and most efficient supply chain route possible, with content ratings having a potential effect on the speed, cost, and production facility that your order is sent to.
While this sounds like a simple logistical process, some creators point out that charging more money to print comics based on the content of that comic is a form of economic censorship, designed to have a chilling effect on these creators. Now there are several factors that impact the cost of comic book printing. Domestic, regional, and international printers all have different prices. Paper stock and finish also changes the price, as does the size and requested speed of your order. There are even printers who won’t print what they deem to be adult material. The only wrinkle in the Mixam situation is their decision to squeeze more money out of creators instead of simply rejecting the order. Adult comics will continue to face challenges in the domestic culture wars. Creators and publishers who work in this space need to navigate even more hurdles than their mainstream counterparts.
Digital Sharecropping and Comic Book Publishing: Here’s a rant that isn’t about comics, but is very important to comics. Marketing is essential to publishing comics. During the 21st century, online marketing, especially social media marketing, is a major component of that process. It takes the form of crowdfunding posts, promotional videos, or general community engagement. One of the major reasons why social media marketing is prevalent in comics is because it is largely free. Unless you’re paying for ads or an influencer, the only obvious upfront cost is your time. But a creator I follow outside of comics recently reminded me of a major pitfall in this process.
There is a social media comedian who built up an audience of several million people across multiple social media channels over a period of ten years. He got so big online that he quit his day job to create content full-time. He also got big enough to attract haters and trolls. Over the summer, they were able to get half of his social media accounts suspended or closed, costing him half of his audience and even more of his revenue. This is an example of what is known as digital sharecropping. It takes its name from a sublimated form of slavery after the Civil War and refers to the process of building a business on a platform that you do not own or control. The fallacy in social media is that you can have the attention of millions of fans or followers. The reality is that YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram have those people’s attention. They allow you to access those people, and they can cut you off from all of them any time they want, for any reason or no reason at all. If all your connections to your colleagues, fans, and readers come from social media, then your business is on very shaky ground.
The solution that I often suggest to my clients is working as hard as possible to move people off social media and onto your mailing list. Once a person gives you their email address, either in a crowdfunding campaign or because they joined your newsletter, it doesn’t matter what social media does or doesn’t give you access to. You will still have a direct connection to your community. It requires more effort and more money, but no one wants to wake up one day to find their entire comic book business has been crippled by an algorithm or a troll.
Digital Delays: While other forms of narrative entertainment have expanded into digital distribution at an exponential rate, comics are still primarily a print medium. Digital comics threatened to be the next big thing fifteen years ago, but Comixology collapsed after being folded into Amazon’s Kindle App, and Webtoon has lost more than 60% of its share value since its IPO in 2024. New players are still trying to build this side of the business, as both longstanding comics publishers and upstart digital retailers have carved out new approaches to producing, selling, and reaching an audience for online comics, but this is still a very difficult business from both a revenue and a reader perspective.
According to Publisher’s Weekly, digital comic book sales only account for 5-10% of total revenue for any publisher, and readers from Gen X, Millennials, Gen Z, and Gen Alpha all display a preference for print over digital for different demographic reasons. Independent publishers definitely get greater access to potential readers through digital platforms, and 10% additional revenue is not insignificant. The solution might be to leverage digital distribution as an enhanced marketing strategy and put the bulk of your sales efforts into print until digital comics become more profitable, if they ever become more profitable.
If you have a question, comment, criticism, or joke related to The Business of Comics, please leave a comment.
If you are working on a deal for your comic, or if you need ongoing legal support for your comic book business, please contact me for a free consultation.
Have fun.
Gamal
PLEASE NOTE: THIS BLOG POST IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR LEGAL ADVICE. IF YOU HAVE A CONTENT, LICENSING OR INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY ISSUE, DISCUSS IT WITH YOUR LEGAL ADVISOR OR CONTACT C3 FOR A FREE CONSULTATION.
